Files
website/server/src/engagement/engine.js
wtclaude 7d3d6d5abd
Some checks failed
PR Checks / client-build (pull_request) Successful in 45s
PR Checks / server-tests (pull_request) Failing after 5m47s
PR Checks / bot-tests (pull_request) Successful in 8m27s
feat(events): the integrations — lifecycle triggers, participants, results (Phase 10)
`EVENTS_PLAN.md` Phase 10. Core registers its own `event.` triggers, records who
took part, publishes a results table, and announces a post through the legs the
news pipeline already uses. Events owns none of the delivery: a run says what
happened and an operator's rule decides who is told, so email, the in-app inbox,
push tickles, Discord and the town crier all arrive without anything in
`events/` growing a second delivery path.

**No route was added and nothing moved.** The whole surface is two more derived
fields on a run — `participants` and `resultsPublishedAt` — and a zero-line
`routes.manifest.json` diff proves it.

Seven triggers: six at ceiling `authenticated` / audience `subscribers`, exactly
where `news.post` sits, and `run.failed` at `admin` on both halves. Every one
keys its cooldown on the RUN. Two rules seeded, both off, under a third one-shot
key so a deployment that has already stamped the Team and news keys still gets
them.

**The phase's own defect was a promise nothing kept.** `EVENTS.md` §I says a
rehearsal runs for real "with announcements ceilinged to `staff`" — but a
ceiling is declared on the TRIGGER, and a rehearsal fires the same trigger as
the real thing, so the moment this phase gave a run something to announce,
rehearsing a published event would have mailed every subscriber. The emit
envelope now takes an optional `ceiling` and the send-time G24 gate applies
`meet(declared, emitted)`. It only narrows; two incomparable ceilings refuse
every rule rather than resolving to either.

`MODULE_API_VERSION` stays 1.10.0, amended in place — `main` declares 1.9.0, so
1.10.0 has not shipped and the org lead's 2026-09-03 rule applies for the third
time.

Three defects the live walk found, none visible to a unit test:

1. **A channel that reported success while reaching nobody.** The seeded
   `run.started` rule named `push`, because §8.5 and the plan both do. Push
   delivery joins `notification_subscriptions`, only ever written for an id the
   preferences screen offered push for — and it offers push only for a
   registered STREAM. So the tickle went nowhere every time while
   `pushChannel.deliver` answered "tickle published". `event.run.started` is now
   a stream as well as a trigger; the other six are not.
2. **A trigger's `description` reaches a recipient.** It is the structural
   projection's `intro` fallback, so `run.failed`'s line ending "Staff-facing."
   put those words in an administrator's own inbox item.
3. **`affectedRows` cannot tell an insert from an unchanged upsert.** The
   connector sends `CLIENT_FOUND_ROWS`, so a "was this new" flag would have
   counted every idempotent retried collect as a fresh participant.

And one caught before it shipped: ranking with a session variable is wrong here,
because `query()` takes a pool connection per call — the variable would be set
on one connection and read on another. A window function needs no session state.

## Verification

- `npm test --prefix server` — **1981 pass, 1 fail**, and that one
  (`botScore.test.js`) passes standalone at 18/18: a file-level flake under
  parallel load. Run with an empty `MODULES_DIR`, as CI does.
- `npm test --prefix client` — 362 pass, 0 fail. `npm run build` green.
- Zero-line `routes.manifest.json` / `routes.guards.json` diff.
- A live walk on a real rig: MariaDB, the site with no module, mailpit. The mail
  arrived, headed with the event's title and its start time in the shard's own
  zone; the rehearsal fired the same trigger and produced zero outbox rows where
  the real run produced three; `run.failed` reached the administrator's inbox
  and no player's; `core.announce.post` queued a second job without touching the
  news pipeline's back-pointer or `announced_at`; and `rankRun` and the upsert
  were run against real MariaDB 11.

## One thing for a reviewer, out of scope and not fixed

**Every `#swagger.description` in this repo is truncated in the generated spec.**
swagger-autogen does not honour a backslash-escaped apostrophe, so a description
is cut at the first `\'` — 175 of the 177 in `server/src/router/**`. It is
pre-existing and repo-wide. Only the one annotation this phase edits is fixed
here (a typographic apostrophe), because otherwise this phase's own addition to
it would be dead text. The rest wants its own change.

- [x] AI-assisted: Claude Code (Opus 5).

Docs: RunicGateway/docs#TBD.

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)
2026-09-04 13:06:46 -05:00

337 lines
14 KiB
JavaScript

// ── The engagement engine ──────────────────────────────────────────────────
//
// ENGAGEMENT.md Phase 4a. `ctx.events.emit` validated a payload against a
// declaration and stopped (Phase 2); this is what it now hands the validated
// event to. The engine's whole job is to answer, for one event, **who gets told,
// on what, and not too often** - and then to write that down as outbox rows.
// It never delivers: `engagementWorker` drains the outbox, and what actually
// carries a message arrives with the channels' `deliver` in Phases 6 and 7.
//
// **The order of the gates is the design, and each one is here because skipping
// it is a way to mail the wrong people or too many of them:**
//
// 1. enabled rules for this trigger - nothing is seeded, nothing is on by default
// 2. conditions - is this particular firing interesting
// 3. audience -> user ids - core's tables, or a composed segment
// 4. ceiling re-check (G24) - re-run at SEND time, not only at save
// 5. per-channel preference - a user's own opt-in, effective mode
// 6. per-rule hourly ceiling (§7.1 Q3) - the hard stop that makes rules-as-data safe
// 7. cooldown, per (rule, user, subject) - one statement, so two emits cannot race
// 8. enqueue, deduped - a replayed event is one row, not two
//
// Steps 6 and 7 are in that order deliberately. The hourly ceiling is about the
// RULE and is the thing that stops a mail storm; the cooldown is about one
// recipient and one subject. Checking the cheap global bound before consuming a
// per-recipient cooldown slot means a rule that has hit its ceiling does not also
// silently burn everybody's cooldowns on sends that never happen.
//
// **Nothing here throws at its caller.** It is invoked from inside a game-event
// handler by way of `ctx.events.emit`, and a database problem of core's must not
// become a module's control flow (the same posture the emit validator takes).
const rulesDb = require('../model/engagement/engagementRules.db')
const outboxDb = require('../model/engagement/engagementOutbox.db')
const cooldownsDb = require('../model/engagement/engagementCooldowns.db')
const sendsDb = require('../model/engagement/engagementSends.db')
const recipients = require('../model/engagement/engagementRecipients.db')
const conditions = require('./conditions')
const audiences = require('./audiences')
const channels = require('./channels')
const scopedPrefs = require('./scopedPrefs')
const log = require('../utils/logger')('engagement')
const HOUR_MS = 60 * 60 * 1000
// Channels one of whose payloads can REFERENCE another's result, earliest first
// (Phase 7). Only one pair qualifies today: a push tickle's `ref` deep-links to
// the inbox row `inapp` writes, and the outbox is swept `ORDER BY due_at, id`,
// so enqueueing in-app first is what makes that ref resolve on the first pass
// rather than on a retry. Everything not named here keeps the operator's own
// order, which is the order the rules screen shows.
//
// It is an ordering, not a dependency: `pushChannel` treats a missing ref as
// null and the app pulls regardless, so a rule that names only push, or a row
// that gets retried out of sequence, is still correct.
const CHANNEL_ORDER = ['inapp']
const channelRank = (id) => {
const i = CHANNEL_ORDER.indexOf(id)
return i === -1 ? CHANNEL_ORDER.length : i
}
/**
* Which of a rule's channels are actually deliverable right now?
*
* A rule stores channel ids as data (`channels JSON`), so it can name one whose
* module has been removed since. An unregistered channel is dropped rather than
* failing the rule: the other channels of that rule are still correct, and a
* dropped one is visible in the log line below.
*/
const liveChannels = (rule) =>
(rule.channels || [])
.filter((c) => channels.has(c))
.sort((a, b) => channelRank(a) - channelRank(b))
/**
* The EFFECTIVE mode each candidate holds for (id, channel), given the event's
* scope.
*
* Effective, not stored: a row exists only where a user has expressed something,
* and absence means the channel's `defaultMode` (§3.1). Reading the stored rows
* and applying the default here keeps that answer in the registry, which is the
* invariant Phase 3 established.
*
* **A scoped preference wins outright where one exists** (Phase 6, decision 4).
* `team_notification_prefs` stayed where it is and `scopedPrefs` is the adapter;
* for a Team-scoped event that table is the preference, exactly as it has been
* since Teams shipped. The argument for replacing rather than intersecting is in
* scopedPrefs.js's header, and it is short: intersecting would have silenced
* every existing Team-email subscriber on the deploy that migrated them.
*/
async function effectiveModes(userIds, streamId, channel, scopeKey) {
const modes = new Map()
if (!userIds.length) return modes
const scoped = await scopedPrefs.resolve(userIds, channel, scopeKey)
const stored = await recipients.storedModes(userIds, streamId, channel)
const fallback = channels.defaultMode(channel)
for (const id of userIds) modes.set(id, scoped.get(id) ?? stored.get(id) ?? fallback)
return modes
}
/**
* The candidates who should get an OUTBOX ROW for this channel.
*
* `off` is excluded for the obvious reason. **`digest` is excluded too, and that
* corrects what Phase 4a said here** — its comment read "a 'digest' preference is
* kept, not dropped… what changes in Phase 6 is who drains it", and what changed
* in Phase 6 is that nothing drains it. §4.2b keeps `teamDigestWorker`'s
* compute-at-send-time design, so a digest is re-derived from the source tables
* when it goes out, not assembled from snapshots taken hours earlier. An outbox
* row for a digest recipient would be a second copy of the content with none of
* the three properties that design exists for — most importantly, it would mail
* a user who lost access between the post and the send.
*/
async function subscribedTo(userIds, streamId, channel, scopeKey = null) {
const modes = await effectiveModes(userIds, streamId, channel, scopeKey)
return userIds.filter((id) => modes.get(id) === 'instant')
}
/**
* Run one rule against one event. Returns a small summary, for the log line and
* for tests; it is not read by the caller for control flow.
*/
async function applyRule(rule, event, now) {
const summary = {
ruleId: rule.id,
enqueued: 0,
deduped: 0,
cooled: 0,
capped: 0,
// Phase 9: people a CHANNEL refused to enqueue for, by reason. Counted
// separately from `cooled` and `capped` because those are the engine holding
// a message back and this is a channel saying it cannot carry one at all.
ineligible: {},
skipped: null,
}
if (!conditions.evaluate(rule.conditions, event.data)) {
summary.skipped = 'conditions'
return summary
}
const resolved = await audiences.resolveForRule(rule, event)
if (resolved.dormant) {
summary.skipped = resolved.reason || 'dormant'
return summary
}
if (!resolved.userIds.length) {
summary.skipped = resolved.reason || 'empty audience'
return summary
}
// G24, re-run at send time. A rule saved when its trigger permitted a wider
// audience must not keep reaching it after a module upgrade narrowed the
// declaration - and that was the only way this could fail, since the save path
// ran the same check.
//
// **Phase 10 gave it a second way, and it is the one that fires in practice:**
// the event may carry a narrowing ceiling of its own. A rehearsal emits
// `event.run.started` with `ceiling: 'staff'`, and every rule an operator wrote
// for the real thing is then refused here rather than mailing subscribers about
// an event that is not happening. Nothing about the rule changed; the occasion
// did. See `audiences.permitted`.
if (!audiences.permitted(event.triggerId, resolved.ceiling, event.ceiling)) {
log.warn('rule audience exceeds its trigger ceiling - refusing', {
rule: rule.id,
trigger: event.triggerId,
audience: resolved.ceiling,
emitted: event.ceiling || null,
})
summary.skipped = 'ceiling'
return summary
}
const live = liveChannels(rule)
if (!live.length) {
summary.skipped = 'no registered channel'
return summary
}
// The per-rule hourly ceiling (§7.1 Q3). Counted once for the whole event
// rather than per channel: an operator setting "100 an hour" means a hundred
// messages, not a hundred per channel per event.
const sentThisHour = await sendsDb.countSentSince(rule.id, new Date(now.getTime() - HOUR_MS))
let budget = Math.max(0, rule.max_sends_per_hour - sentThisHour)
if (budget === 0) {
log.warn('rule is at its hourly send ceiling', {
rule: rule.id,
trigger: event.triggerId,
ceiling: rule.max_sends_per_hour,
})
summary.skipped = 'hourly ceiling'
return summary
}
const subjectKey = (event.subject ?? '').toString().slice(0, 190)
const dueAt = new Date(now.getTime() + Math.max(0, rule.delay_seconds) * 1000)
for (const channel of live) {
// Phase 9, and it runs BEFORE the preference filter rather than after. Both
// orders reach the same recipients; this one costs one query against the
// narrower set only when the channel declares an `eligible` at all, and it
// means `summary.ineligible` counts people the CHANNEL cannot reach rather
// than people who happened to also be opted in. Channels that declare none —
// push and in-app — pass straight through.
const gated = await channels.eligibleFor(channel, resolved.userIds)
for (const [why, n] of Object.entries(gated.excluded)) {
summary.ineligible[why] = (summary.ineligible[why] || 0) + n
}
const eligible = await subscribedTo(gated.userIds, event.triggerId, channel, event.scopeKey)
for (const userId of eligible) {
if (budget <= 0) {
summary.capped += 1
continue
}
// Guarded on the interval, so two concurrent emits cannot both pass a
// read-then-write check (§4.1).
//
// **Keyed on the CHANNEL as well**, which is what makes this loop correct
// rather than what makes it work. Without the channel, the first channel of
// a rule claims the cooldown and every later one is refused as cooling —
// and `inapp` is ranked first above, so a rule naming email + in-app would
// deliver the in-app item and silently never the mail. Found on Phase 11b's
// live rig; a cooldown is per delivery, not per occasion.
const allowed = await cooldownsDb.claim(
rule.id, userId, subjectKey, channel, rule.cooldown_seconds, now,
)
if (!allowed) {
summary.cooled += 1
continue
}
const id = await outboxDb.enqueue({
rule_id: rule.id,
trigger_id: event.triggerId,
user_id: userId,
channel,
subject_key: subjectKey,
// The scope a PREFERENCE and an UNSUBSCRIBE are keyed on, which is not
// `subject_key`: for the Team triggers the subject is `teamName` (what a
// cooldown counts) and the scope is `team:12` (what survives a rename).
scope_key: event.scopeKey ?? null,
payload: event.data,
// Scoped per (rule, user, channel) by the unique index, so one event
// fanned out to fifty people is fifty rows carrying the same key.
dedupe_key: event.dedupeKey,
due_at: dueAt,
})
if (id === null) summary.deduped += 1
else {
summary.enqueued += 1
budget -= 1
}
}
}
return summary
}
/**
* Cancel pending rows that this event resolves (§4.2a).
*
* This is the actual point of `delay_seconds`: without cancellation a delay is
* just a late mail. A house repaired back to LikeNew fires a trigger that some
* rule names in its `cancel_on`, and every still-scheduled row for that
* (rule, subject) stops.
*
* When the resolving event names an owner, only that user's rows are cancelled;
* when it does not, every user queued about that subject is - which is the
* house-repaired case, where the event is about the house and not about any one
* of the people who were going to be told.
*/
async function applyCancellations(event, summary) {
const rules = await rulesDb.enabledCancelledBy(event.triggerId)
if (!rules.length) return
const subjectKey = (event.subject ?? '').toString().slice(0, 190)
for (const rule of rules) {
const n = await outboxDb.cancel(rule.id, subjectKey, event.ownerUserId || null)
if (n) {
summary.cancelled += n
log.info('cancelled scheduled sends', {
rule: rule.id,
by: event.triggerId,
subject: subjectKey,
rows: n,
})
}
}
}
/**
* Dispatch one validated event. Called by `engagementEmit.emit` after the payload
* has been checked against the declaration.
*
* @param {object} event the envelope `engagementEmit` built
* @returns {Promise<{ rules: number, enqueued: number, cancelled: number }>}
*/
async function dispatch(event, now = new Date()) {
const summary = { rules: 0, enqueued: 0, deduped: 0, cooled: 0, capped: 0, cancelled: 0 }
try {
const rules = await rulesDb.enabledForTrigger(event.triggerId)
summary.rules = rules.length
for (const rule of rules) {
const result = await applyRule(rule, event, now)
summary.enqueued += result.enqueued
summary.deduped += result.deduped
summary.cooled += result.cooled
summary.capped += result.capped
}
await applyCancellations(event, summary)
// Keys and counts, never values - the same rule the emit log line follows.
// A payload carries player names, house locations and forum excerpts, and a
// log that reproduces them is a second copy of exactly the content
// `engagement_sends` is careful to keep out of the database.
if (summary.rules || summary.cancelled) {
log.info('event dispatched', { trigger: event.triggerId, ...summary })
}
} catch (err) {
// A database problem of core's must not become the module's control flow at
// three in the morning. The emit already succeeded as a contract; what failed
// is delivery, and it is logged as core's failure.
log.error('dispatch failed', { trigger: event.triggerId, message: err.message })
}
return summary
}
module.exports = {
dispatch,
applyRule,
applyCancellations,
subscribedTo,
effectiveModes,
liveChannels,
CHANNEL_ORDER,
HOUR_MS,
}