Files
website/server/test/shardVisibility.test.js
wtclaude f30ea66fce fix(shard): enforce visibility on the REST reads that bypassed it
Protocol 3.0 Part A follow-up, found by the live five-rung smoke test.

Part A implemented the visibility framework correctly on the SSE path
and on /guilds + /governors, but the remaining public REST reads never
called into it. The result was that one event was projected live and
served verbatim from history:

  * GET /public/shard/feed returned the stored payload as-is, so
    actor.acct and actor.webId were readable ANONYMOUSLY for every
    logged kind - player.death, player.murdered, mob.killed,
    quest.complete, skill.gain, fame/karma.change, mob.login/logout,
    guild.join. Broader than the guild-leader leak Part A set out to
    close, since it covers every player rather than board holders.

  * GET /public/shard/idoc returned ownerAcct - the house owner's game
    account - to anonymous callers.

  * The `houses` field rules (owner/price -> staff) were dead config:
    neither getIdoc nor getHouses projected, so an admin could set them
    in the panel and nothing happened.

  * /feed filtered on PUBLIC_KINDS, a module-load constant derived from
    the compiled DEFAULTS, so live audience changes did not reach it.
    With `guilds` moved to staff, /guilds 403'd while /feed happily
    served guild.join to anonymous.

Four fixes, all at the root rather than per-route:

1. Rule 1 now matches a field's MEANING, not one spelling. The wire
   nests actors (leader.acct) but the read models flatten them
   (shapeHouse -> ownerAcct, shapeGuild -> leaderWebId), and an
   exact-key check missed every flattened one. isLockedField() locks a
   key that is or ends in acct/webId, case-insensitively, so it fails
   closed for shapes not yet written. The admin PUT rejects those
   spellings too - `ownerAcct` is no longer configurable.

2. visibleKinds(level, config) resolves readable kinds from the LIVE
   config; getFeed uses it and projects each row against its own kind's
   feature. Deliberately independent of the `stream` flag, which governs
   SSE fan-out only - so market history stays readable with its firehose
   off. This makes the set a superset of PUBLIC_KINDS by exactly the two
   vendor kinds.

3. getIdoc/getHouses/getChamps/getPresence project, so every shard
   surface honours the same config.

4. shardEvents.db.list treats an EMPTY kinds array as "serve nothing".
   It previously fell through to the unfiltered query, so a fully-gated
   config would have dumped the whole event log, staff audit included.

Also fixes a bug introduced while wiring this up: projectValue recursed
into any object, so a Date column came back as {}. It now walks arrays
and plain objects only. The unit tests used JSON fixtures and could not
have caught it - the live /idoc read did.

Verified live against MariaDB + a stub sidecar, all five rungs: 13
routes x 5 rungs, defaults reproducing pre-v3 access exactly, zero
acct/webId below admin on any read, unmapped kinds (staff.command,
cheat.detect, login.attempt) reaching only admin on SSE, and audience /
enabled / stream changes taking effect live on an already-open stream.

Tests: 487 server (+9). Swagger regenerated; route manifest unchanged.

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-07-28 10:49:55 -05:00

381 lines
17 KiB
JavaScript

// Point the DB at a closed port BEFORE requiring anything that builds a pool.
// Every DB call this suite would make is monkeypatched.
process.env.DB_HOST = '127.0.0.1'
process.env.DB_PORT = '59999'
const { test, after, afterEach, beforeEach } = require('node:test')
const assert = require('node:assert/strict')
// Unit-test the visibility framework's INVARIANTS — the rules that make it a
// security boundary rather than a convenience filter (docs/link/v3.md §3):
//
// 1. acct / webId are admin-only ALWAYS and cannot be configured down.
// 2. A kind absent from KIND_FEATURE reaches nobody below admin (fail closed).
// 3. The compiled defaults reproduce pre-v3 behavior, so installing this
// module changes nothing until an admin edits the config.
// 4. The ladder is ordered and each rung implies the ones below it.
const visibility = require('../src/utils/shardVisibility')
const model = require('../src/model/shardVisibility/shardVisibility.model')
const shardLinks = require('../src/model/shardLinks/shardLinks.model')
const db = require('../src/utils/db')
after(() => db.close())
const originals = { listAll: model.listAll, listForUser: shardLinks.listForUser }
// Default both DB reads to "no rows" so a test that doesn't care never blocks on
// the dead pool (each such call would otherwise burn the 10s acquire timeout).
// Tests that exercise stored config or a DB failure override these.
beforeEach(() => {
model.listAll = async () => []
shardLinks.listForUser = async () => []
visibility.invalidate()
})
afterEach(() => {
model.listAll = originals.listAll
shardLinks.listForUser = originals.listForUser
visibility.invalidate()
})
// Stub the stored config; the framework merges rows over compiled defaults.
function withRows(rows) {
model.listAll = async () => rows
visibility.invalidate()
}
// ── The ladder ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
test('ladder is ordered and each rung implies the ones below it', () => {
assert.deepEqual(visibility.LADDER, ['anonymous', 'logged_in', 'player', 'staff', 'admin'])
for (let i = 0; i < visibility.LADDER.length; i += 1) {
for (let j = 0; j <= i; j += 1) {
assert.equal(visibility.meets(visibility.LADDER[i], visibility.LADDER[j]), true)
}
for (let j = i + 1; j < visibility.LADDER.length; j += 1) {
assert.equal(visibility.meets(visibility.LADDER[i], visibility.LADDER[j]), false)
}
}
})
test('an unknown rung always loses, on BOTH sides of the comparison', () => {
assert.equal(visibility.isLevel('not-a-rung'), false)
// An unknown REQUIREMENT is satisfied by nobody below admin...
for (const level of ['anonymous', 'logged_in', 'player', 'staff']) {
assert.equal(visibility.meets(level, 'not-a-rung'), false, `${level} vs unknown requirement`)
}
assert.equal(visibility.meets('admin', 'not-a-rung'), true)
// ...and an unknown VIEWER level grants nothing. This is the direction that
// matters: a shared admin fallback would have made a garbage viewer level
// pass every gate.
for (const required of visibility.LADDER.slice(1)) {
assert.equal(visibility.meets('not-a-rung', required), false, `unknown viewer vs ${required}`)
assert.equal(visibility.meets(undefined, required), false, `undefined viewer vs ${required}`)
assert.equal(visibility.meets(null, required), false, `null viewer vs ${required}`)
}
})
test('an unknown viewer level cannot see a gated kind or a locked field', async () => {
const config = await visibility.getConfig()
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('champ.update', 'not-a-rung', config), true) // anonymous-tier: fine
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('audit.command', 'not-a-rung', config), false)
const out = visibility.projectFeature(
'guilds',
{ leader: { name: 'Darrow', acct: 'whitlocktech', webId: '42' } },
'not-a-rung',
config,
)
assert.equal('acct' in out.leader, false)
assert.equal('webId' in out.leader, false)
})
// ── Rule 1: locked fields ──────────────────────────────────────────────────
test('acct and webId are stripped below admin regardless of feature config', () => {
const config = visibility.compileDefaults()
const frame = {
kind: 'guild.update',
name: 'The Nameless',
leader: { serial: '0x1A2B', name: 'Darrow', acct: 'whitlocktech', webId: '42', player: true },
}
for (const level of ['anonymous', 'logged_in', 'player', 'staff']) {
const out = visibility.projectFeature('guilds', frame, level, config)
assert.equal(out.leader.name, 'Darrow', `${level} keeps the character name`)
assert.equal(out.leader.serial, '0x1A2B')
assert.equal('acct' in out.leader, false, `${level} must not see acct`)
assert.equal('webId' in out.leader, false, `${level} must not see webId`)
}
const asAdmin = visibility.projectFeature('guilds', frame, 'admin', config)
assert.equal(asAdmin.leader.acct, 'whitlocktech')
assert.equal(asAdmin.leader.webId, '42')
})
test('a stored rule trying to loosen a locked field is ignored', async () => {
withRows([
{ feature: 'guilds', enabled: true, audience: 'anonymous', stream: true, fieldRules: { acct: 'anonymous', webId: 'anonymous' } },
])
const config = await visibility.getConfig()
const out = visibility.projectFeature(
'guilds',
{ leader: { name: 'Darrow', acct: 'whitlocktech', webId: '42' } },
'anonymous',
config,
)
assert.equal('acct' in out.leader, false)
assert.equal('webId' in out.leader, false)
})
test('rule 1 matches FLATTENED spellings, not just the two canonical keys', () => {
const config = visibility.compileDefaults()
// shapeHouse/shapeGuild flatten the actor into `<role>Acct` / `<role>WebId`.
// An exact-key check missed every one of these, which is how GET
// /public/shard/idoc served the owner's game account to anonymous callers.
const row = {
serial: '0x1',
name: 'Marble Tower',
ownerAcct: 'cadmus_acct',
leaderWebId: 42,
governorAcct: 'blackthorn_acct',
}
const out = visibility.projectFeature('houses', row, 'staff', config)
assert.equal('ownerAcct' in out, false, 'staff must not see a flattened acct')
assert.equal('leaderWebId' in out, false)
assert.equal('governorAcct' in out, false)
assert.equal(out.name, 'Marble Tower', 'ordinary fields are untouched')
const asAdmin = visibility.projectFeature('houses', row, 'admin', config)
assert.equal(asAdmin.ownerAcct, 'cadmus_acct')
})
test('isLockedField locks acct/webId and their suffixed forms, and nothing else', () => {
for (const key of ['acct', 'webId', 'WEBID', 'ownerAcct', 'leaderWebId', 'governorAcct']) {
assert.equal(visibility.isLockedField(key), true, `${key} must be locked`)
}
// Must not over-match: these are ordinary public fields.
for (const key of ['name', 'serial', 'ownerName', 'price', 'contact', 'region']) {
assert.equal(visibility.isLockedField(key), false, `${key} must stay configurable`)
}
})
test('a Date survives projection instead of collapsing to {}', () => {
const config = visibility.compileDefaults()
const when = new Date('2026-07-06T19:32:29.000Z')
// The DB-backed read models carry real Date columns; rebuilding one key-by-key
// yields `{}` because a Date has no enumerable own properties.
const out = visibility.projectFeature('houses', { name: 'Keep', updatedAt: when }, 'anonymous', config)
assert.ok(out.updatedAt instanceof Date)
assert.equal(out.updatedAt.toISOString(), when.toISOString())
})
test('visibleKinds tracks live config and stays independent of the stream flag', async () => {
const config = visibility.compileDefaults()
assert.ok(visibleIncludes(config, 'anonymous', 'guild.update'))
// `stream: false` suppresses SSE fan-out only — the stored history stays readable.
assert.ok(visibleIncludes(config, 'anonymous', 'vendor.listing'))
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('vendor.listing', 'anonymous', config), false)
const gated = { ...config, guilds: { ...config.guilds, audience: 'staff' } }
assert.equal(visibleIncludes(gated, 'anonymous', 'guild.update'), false)
assert.ok(visibleIncludes(gated, 'staff', 'guild.update'))
const off = { ...config, guilds: { ...config.guilds, enabled: false } }
assert.equal(visibleIncludes(off, 'admin', 'guild.update'), false)
// Rule 2 still holds: an unmapped kind is in nobody's readable set.
assert.equal(visibleIncludes(config, 'admin', 'staff.audit'), false)
})
const visibleIncludes = (config, level, kind) => visibility.visibleKinds(level, config).includes(kind)
test('projection recurses into arrays and nested actors', () => {
const config = visibility.compileDefaults()
const rows = [
{ city: 'Britain', governor: { name: 'A', acct: 'a', webId: '1' } },
{ city: 'Vesper', governor: { name: 'B', acct: 'b' } },
]
const out = visibility.projectFeature('governors', rows, 'anonymous', config)
assert.equal(out.length, 2)
assert.equal(out[0].governor.name, 'A')
assert.equal('acct' in out[0].governor, false)
assert.equal('webId' in out[0].governor, false)
assert.equal('acct' in out[1].governor, false)
})
// ── Rule 2: fail closed on unmapped kinds ──────────────────────────────────
test('an unmapped kind reaches nobody below admin', async () => {
const config = await visibility.getConfig()
for (const kind of ['audit.command', 'cheat.fastwalk', 'account.login.attempt', 'gold.change', 'made.up.kind']) {
for (const level of ['anonymous', 'logged_in', 'player', 'staff']) {
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo(kind, level, config), false, `${kind} @ ${level}`)
}
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo(kind, 'admin', config), true, `${kind} @ admin`)
}
})
test('the full house registry stays off the kind map (owner/price are staff-only)', () => {
assert.equal(visibility.KIND_FEATURE.has('house.update'), false)
assert.equal(visibility.KIND_FEATURE.has('house.remove'), false)
// house.decay — the IDOC signal the public page renders — IS mapped.
assert.equal(visibility.KIND_FEATURE.get('house.decay'), 'houses')
})
test('vendor.sale is not public (sales are owner-private)', async () => {
const config = await visibility.getConfig()
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('vendor.sale', 'anonymous', config), false)
assert.equal(visibility.PUBLIC_KINDS.has('vendor.sale'), false)
})
// ── Rule 3: defaults reproduce pre-v3 behavior ─────────────────────────────
// The exact allowlist that shipped in shardBroadcast.js before v3. If a change
// makes the derived PUBLIC_KINDS differ from this, it is a deliberate widening
// or narrowing of what anonymous visitors see and must be reviewed as such.
const PRE_V3_PUBLIC_KINDS = [
'player.death',
'player.murdered',
'mob.killed',
'house.decay',
'quest.complete',
'skill.gain',
'fame.change',
'karma.change',
'mob.login',
'mob.logout',
'economy.supply',
'server.hello',
'server.shutdown',
'server.crashed',
'champ.update',
'champ.remove',
'guild.update',
'guild.remove',
'guild.join',
'city.update',
'presence.online',
'region.enter',
]
// The kinds v3 deliberately ADDS to the anonymous set. vendor.listing is
// pointedly not among them (its feature ships with stream off).
const V3_ADDED_PUBLIC_KINDS = ['world.ruleset', 'points.board']
test('derived PUBLIC_KINDS is exactly the pre-v3 allowlist plus the v3 additions', () => {
assert.deepEqual(
[...visibility.PUBLIC_KINDS].sort(),
[...PRE_V3_PUBLIC_KINDS, ...V3_ADDED_PUBLIC_KINDS].sort(),
)
})
test('no pre-v3 public kind was dropped', () => {
for (const kind of PRE_V3_PUBLIC_KINDS) {
assert.equal(visibility.PUBLIC_KINDS.has(kind), true, `${kind} fell out of the public set`)
}
})
test('the market stream is off by default but its REST feature is not', async () => {
const config = await visibility.getConfig()
assert.equal(config.market.enabled, true)
assert.equal(config.market.audience, 'anonymous')
assert.equal(config.market.stream, false)
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('vendor.listing', 'anonymous', config), false)
assert.equal(visibility.PUBLIC_KINDS.has('vendor.listing'), false)
})
test('presence location defaults to staff, matching the old admin/moderator gate', async () => {
const config = await visibility.getConfig()
assert.equal(config.presence.fields.location, 'staff')
assert.equal(visibility.meets('player', 'staff'), false)
assert.equal(visibility.meets('staff', 'staff'), true)
})
test('every mapped kind names a real feature', () => {
for (const [kind, feature] of visibility.KIND_FEATURE) {
assert.equal(visibility.isFeature(feature), true, `${kind} → unknown feature ${feature}`)
}
})
// ── Config merge ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
test('a disabled feature is invisible to everyone below admin', async () => {
withRows([{ feature: 'champs', enabled: false, audience: 'anonymous', stream: true, fieldRules: {} }])
const config = await visibility.getConfig()
assert.equal(config.champs.enabled, false)
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('champ.update', 'anonymous', config), false)
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('champ.update', 'staff', config), false)
assert.equal(visibility.visibleFeatures('staff', config).includes('champs'), false)
})
test('raising a feature audience gates the lower rungs out', async () => {
withRows([{ feature: 'guilds', enabled: true, audience: 'player', stream: true, fieldRules: {} }])
const config = await visibility.getConfig()
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('guild.update', 'anonymous', config), false)
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('guild.update', 'logged_in', config), false)
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('guild.update', 'player', config), true)
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('guild.update', 'staff', config), true)
})
test('an unknown stored feature name is ignored, not resurrected', async () => {
withRows([{ feature: 'sekrit', enabled: true, audience: 'anonymous', stream: true, fieldRules: {} }])
const config = await visibility.getConfig()
assert.equal('sekrit' in config, false)
assert.deepEqual(Object.keys(config).sort(), [...visibility.FEATURE_NAMES].sort())
})
test('an invalid stored rung falls back to the default rather than failing open', async () => {
withRows([{ feature: 'houses', enabled: true, audience: 'nonsense', stream: true, fieldRules: { owner: 'nonsense' } }])
const config = await visibility.getConfig()
assert.equal(config.houses.audience, 'anonymous') // the compiled default
assert.equal(config.houses.fields.owner, 'staff') // the compiled default
})
test('a DB failure degrades to compiled defaults, not to everything-public', async () => {
model.listAll = async () => {
throw new Error('db down')
}
visibility.invalidate()
const config = await visibility.getConfig()
assert.deepEqual(Object.keys(config).sort(), [...visibility.FEATURE_NAMES].sort())
assert.equal(config.presence.fields.location, 'staff')
assert.equal(visibility.kindVisibleTo('audit.command', 'anonymous', config), false)
})
// ── Viewer level ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
test('viewerLevel resolves the ladder from role and link status', async () => {
shardLinks.listForUser = async () => []
assert.equal(await visibility.viewerLevel({}), 'anonymous')
visibility.forgetUser(1)
assert.equal(await visibility.viewerLevel({ user: { id: 1, role: 'admin' } }), 'admin')
visibility.forgetUser(2)
assert.equal(await visibility.viewerLevel({ user: { id: 2, role: 'moderator' } }), 'staff')
// A member with no linked game account sits at logged_in...
visibility.forgetUser(3)
assert.equal(await visibility.viewerLevel({ user: { id: 3, role: 'player' } }), 'logged_in')
// ...and reaches `player` once a link exists.
shardLinks.listForUser = async () => [{ account: 'whitlocktech' }]
visibility.forgetUser(4)
assert.equal(await visibility.viewerLevel({ user: { id: 4, role: 'player' } }), 'player')
})
test('editor is a content role and gets no shard privilege', async () => {
// Mapping editor to `staff` here would silently widen what editors can see;
// today's modAccess gate is admin|moderator only.
shardLinks.listForUser = async () => []
visibility.forgetUser(5)
assert.equal(await visibility.viewerLevel({ user: { id: 5, role: 'editor' } }), 'logged_in')
})
test('a link lookup failure downgrades rather than escalating', async () => {
shardLinks.listForUser = async () => {
throw new Error('db down')
}
visibility.forgetUser(6)
assert.equal(await visibility.viewerLevel({ user: { id: 6, role: 'player' } }), 'logged_in')
})