Companion to website "feat(security): soak the tightened CSP on report-only".
The plan's Phase 1 claimed a two-directive delta, one of which was adding
`form-action 'self'` as "currently absent". It was not absent. The directives
object in app.js does not list it, but the middleware runs `useDefaults: true`
and helmet's default set already supplies it, so production has been serving it
all along. The plan was written from the config rather than from the live
header; the correction, and how it was caught, are now recorded in place rather
than quietly fixed.
That leaves `frame-ancestors 'self'` -> `'none'` as the entire behavioural delta
of the phase. Worth noting that this is also the directive that most justifies a
soak: a frame-ancestors violation is reported by the browser of whoever framed
the site, so it is the only available way to discover a legitimate embed before
an enforcing policy breaks it.
Also documented:
* POST /api/csp-report -- the same-origin sink report-to/report-uri point at,
why it is same-origin, why it lives outside /api/v1, both wire formats, the
Reporting-Endpoints header requirement, and the properties that make an
unauthenticated public POST safe (always-204, caps, truncation, rate limit).
* That the sink is scoped to the soak, so the enforce PR must decide
explicitly whether to retire it or keep a report-to group on the enforced
policy -- rather than leaving an orphan route behind.
* The `[csp]` log tag in section 7.5 as the thing to watch during the soak,
and what silence across one release means.
* client/vite.config.js already sets `modulePreload: { polyfill: false }`, so
the plan's inline-polyfill prerequisite was already satisfied.
api-route-inventory.json moves 199 -> 200 for the new route. That is the PR 0
freeze working as intended: the first manifest diff since the baseline is a
deliberate, reviewed one.
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
448 lines
28 KiB
Markdown
448 lines
28 KiB
Markdown
# Website API — router domain split + CSP hardening
|
|
|
|
Status: **planning** · Target repo: `website/` · Docs owner: this file + `BACKEND_DESIGN.md`
|
|
|
|
> **This file replaces the earlier "API v2" plan** (auth merge → CSP → domain split, with a parallel
|
|
> `/api/v2` mount and an `/api/mobile` facade). Three of those four pieces are **not being built**:
|
|
> the auth merge and the mobile facade are deferred with their reasoning recorded below, and the
|
|
> parallel-version scaffold in [API_V2_SKELETON.md](./API_V2_SKELETON.md) is superseded. The filename
|
|
> is kept so existing links resolve. What remains is genuinely useful work:
|
|
>
|
|
> 1. **CSP hardening** — small, independent, ships on its own cadence.
|
|
> 2. **The domain split** — `admin.routes.js` (1552 lines, 110 routes) broken into one router file per
|
|
> business capability, **in place, with every URL unchanged**. This is the actual driver.
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Why the auth merge is out
|
|
|
|
The original plan replaced httpOnly session cookies with a bearer JWT + rotating refresh token for
|
|
every client, so web and mobile would share one session model. Reasons that no longer hold up:
|
|
|
|
1. **The current model is the more secure one.** httpOnly + SameSite cookies are unreadable from JS
|
|
and carry CSRF protection by default. Every migration target is a sideways or backwards move:
|
|
- Refresh token in `localStorage` → any XSS becomes **persistent full account takeover**, not a
|
|
bounded access-token window. A short access TTL does not help; the attacker mints new pairs.
|
|
- Refresh token in an httpOnly cookie scoped to the refresh endpoint → safe, but that is
|
|
*cookies with extra steps*. It concedes the premise.
|
|
2. **"One session model everywhere" is already true where it matters.** `auth/session.service.js`
|
|
unifies cookie and bearer into a single session, and `auth/token.js` already extracts from either
|
|
`Cookie` or `Authorization: Bearer`. That abstraction is written, working, and paid for. The merge
|
|
would move complexity *out* of `extractToken` and *into* the SPA.
|
|
3. **The cookie codepath survives the merge anyway.** The SSO / email-connect redirect flow must keep
|
|
its short-lived httpOnly tx / PKCE-verifier / pending-TOTP cookies — the browser leaves for the
|
|
IdP and returns with no JS context. So the merge never actually delivered "cookies are gone."
|
|
4. **It carried the plan's most bug-prone work as a dependency.** The admin SSE rewrite
|
|
(`EventSource` → hand-rolled `fetch` + `ReadableStream` + SSE frame parser + reconnect/backoff +
|
|
refresh-on-401) existed *only* to serve the bearer model. Without the merge, the admin stream stays
|
|
on `EventSource` with `withCredentials` and that code is never written.
|
|
5. **It is a contract change with no user-visible payoff**, competing for the same review attention as
|
|
the domain split, which is the thing that actually hurts today.
|
|
|
|
### Dropped with it
|
|
|
|
- v2 bearer auth routes (`/api/v2/auth/{login,refresh,logout,login/totp}`).
|
|
- Deletion of the `setAuthCookie` / `clearAuthCookie` path.
|
|
- `rg_trust` cookie → `X-Trust-Token` header migration for web (the header stays available for native
|
|
clients via `extractTrustToken`, unchanged).
|
|
- `api/client.js` bearer + silent-refresh rewrite.
|
|
- `lib/useShardFeed.js` admin-stream fetch rewrite. **The admin SSE stream stays as-is.**
|
|
|
|
### Kept from it
|
|
|
|
- **CSP hardening** — now its own phase (below). It was justified as a compensating control for a
|
|
JS-held token; it is worth doing regardless, just no longer urgent.
|
|
- **The public/admin SSE allowlist split** — unchanged security boundary, unrelated to session model.
|
|
- **The tx-cookie carve-out reasoning** — recorded here so a future merge attempt doesn't rediscover it.
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Deferred: the auth merge
|
|
|
|
Not cancelled — parked behind trigger conditions. Revisit if **any** of these become true:
|
|
|
|
| Trigger | Why it changes the answer |
|
|
|---|---|
|
|
| The API becomes genuinely cross-origin (separate API host) | `SameSite` cookies stop being the easy path; bearer becomes the natural model. |
|
|
| Third-party or OAuth clients are introduced | Cookies don't serve clients you don't control. |
|
|
| Mobile and web session behavior diverge enough to cause real bugs | The unification argument gets teeth it currently lacks. |
|
|
|
|
If it is ever revived, two specs the original plan lacked must be written **first**:
|
|
|
|
- **Refresh-token reuse detection.** Rotation is only useful with it: replay of an already-consumed
|
|
refresh must revoke the entire token family, not just fail the one request.
|
|
- **Rollback procedure.** Once web clients have discarded their cookies, a bad deploy locks everyone
|
|
out. Needs a documented path back.
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Why there is no `/api/v2`
|
|
|
|
The domain split reorganizes router *files*. It does not need to move a single URL — because the URL
|
|
surface is **already grouped by capability**. Inventory taken from the live Express stack — 196
|
|
`/api/v1` routes, plus three outside it (`GET /api/health`, `GET /api/docs.json`,
|
|
`GET /.well-known/assetlinks.json`) and 2 on the internal port. Full machine-readable list:
|
|
[`api-route-inventory.json`](./api-route-inventory.json).
|
|
|
|
| Group | Routes | Second segment → capability |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| `/admin` | 110 | `shard` 16 · `moderation` 15 · `users` 15 · `wiki` 14 · `posts` 9 · `pages` 7 · `account` 6 · `email` 6 · `uo-link` 5 · `auth` 4 · `invites` 3 · `bot-activity` 2 · `discord-bot` 2 · `settings` 2 · `activity` 1 · `dashboard` 1 · `site-mode` 1 · `uploads` 1 |
|
|
| `/auth` | 42 | `me` 23 · `mobile` 5 · `sso` 4 · `password` 3 · `invite` 2 · `login` 2 · `logout` 1 · `providers` 1 · `register` 1 |
|
|
| `/public` | 24 | `shard` 12 · `wiki` 4 · `pages` 2 · `posts` 2 · `contact` 1 · `settings` 1 · `status` 1 · `version` 1 |
|
|
| `/player` | 20 | `account` 8 · `shard` 8 · `appeals` 4 |
|
|
|
|
Every capability already owns a URL prefix, so each new router file mounts at the prefix it already
|
|
owns and the emitted paths are **byte-identical**. No URL change means no contract change, and no
|
|
contract change means no reason to mount a parallel version.
|
|
|
|
Consequences of doing it in place:
|
|
|
|
- No `/api/v2`, no dual mount, no route-by-route migration, no v1-usage telemetry project, and no
|
|
v1-retirement sequence.
|
|
- `BASE = /api/v1` in `client/src/api/client.js` never changes. The Discord bot's `SITE_PUBLIC_URL`
|
|
never changes. The Android app is untouched.
|
|
- [API_V2_SKELETON.md](./API_V2_SKELETON.md) (the `router/v2/` scaffold) is **superseded and not
|
|
scheduled**. It is kept as the concrete recipe if a real contract break ever forces a versioned API.
|
|
|
|
**Tripwire:** if any endpoint turns out to *need* a new URL, that is a contract change, not a
|
|
refactor. List it explicitly, and reopen the versioning question before writing the code — do not
|
|
smuggle a URL change into a "mechanical" PR.
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Deferred: the `/api/mobile` facade and the app-version floor
|
|
|
|
The earlier plan's Phase 0 stood up a version-agnostic `/api/mobile` namespace and migrated the
|
|
Android app onto it, plus an app-version header and a server-side min-version floor.
|
|
|
|
**Why it was proposed:** the app hardcodes **69** distinct `api/v1/…` paths (`data/api/*.kt`,
|
|
`core/net/ShardStreamClient.kt`, `core/net/HostSelectionInterceptor.kt`,
|
|
`core/auth/sso/SsoAuthManager.kt`), has no version negotiation and no force-update, and installs in
|
|
the wild cannot be forced forward. Under a parallel-`/api/v2` plan that made the app the load-bearing
|
|
coupling: v1 could not be retired until the fleet aged out.
|
|
|
|
**Why it is deferred:** with the split done in place, no URL moves and nothing is being deleted — so
|
|
there is no fleet to sunset and no coupling to break. A facade would add ~70 permanently maintained
|
|
delegate routes plus a contract-test suite to solve a problem that does not currently exist. The
|
|
version floor was scoped to sunsetting the pre-facade fleet, so it goes with it.
|
|
|
|
**If it is ever revived** (the trigger is the mobile contract genuinely needing to diverge from web —
|
|
different response shapes, a mobile-only aggregation endpoint, a real breaking change):
|
|
|
|
- **Start with the alias mount, not a delegate layer:** `apiRouter.use('/mobile', v1Router)` gives the
|
|
app a stable, version-agnostic namespace with identical wiring, identical middleware and zero
|
|
per-route maintenance. Build hand-written delegates only for the routes that actually diverge.
|
|
- **A facade is a security surface, not a convenience alias.** Any hand-written route must carry the
|
|
*same* middleware chain as the route it mirrors (`requireAuth`, `staffOnly`/`adminOnly`, validators,
|
|
the public/admin SSE allowlist split). A re-exposed admin route missing `adminOnly` is privilege
|
|
escalation.
|
|
- **It needs contract tests.** The moment the app pins a namespace, its response shapes are a
|
|
committed contract; an internal refactor that changes a shape must fail a test before it ships to
|
|
installed apps.
|
|
- **The mobile SSE stream stays anonymous** under whatever path it gets — the app sends no
|
|
`Authorization` header.
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Phase 1 — CSP hardening (independent)
|
|
|
|
Previously bundled with the auth merge as a compensating control for a JS-held token. With no token in
|
|
JS, this is **defense in depth on its own merits** — cheap, worth doing, blocking nothing. It has no
|
|
dependency on the domain split and can ship at any time.
|
|
|
|
**Sequencing fix from the original plan:** the old version both "ships with the auth merge" and called
|
|
for a one-release report-only soak. Those contradict. Correct order is **report-only first, observe one
|
|
release, then enforce** — now trivially satisfiable since nothing waits on it.
|
|
|
|
The app already ships a tuned policy (`server/src/app.js`). Two directives are load-bearing and are
|
|
**already correct** — the job is to keep them that way:
|
|
|
|
- `script-src 'self'` — no `'unsafe-inline'` / `'unsafe-eval'`. Primary defense.
|
|
- `connect-src 'self'` — the exfiltration channel. Don't widen it unless the API genuinely becomes
|
|
cross-origin (which would also reopen the auth-merge question — see the trigger table).
|
|
|
|
`style-src 'unsafe-inline'` stays — it permits inline styling, not script execution, and React's
|
|
pervasive `style={{…}}` attributes can't be nonce'd. Not a meaningful hole. The `/api/docs` route keeps
|
|
its deliberately looser policy (swagger-ui injects an inline bootstrap script); that carve-out is
|
|
scoped to the one route and stays scoped.
|
|
|
|
Target enforced policy:
|
|
|
|
```
|
|
default-src 'self';
|
|
script-src 'self';
|
|
connect-src 'self';
|
|
img-src 'self' data: https:;
|
|
style-src 'self' 'unsafe-inline'; /* + fonts.googleapis.com only until fonts are self-hosted */
|
|
font-src 'self'; /* + fonts.gstatic.com only until fonts are self-hosted */
|
|
object-src 'none';
|
|
base-uri 'self';
|
|
form-action 'self';
|
|
frame-ancestors 'none';
|
|
```
|
|
|
|
Delta vs. the policy in `server/src/app.js` today. This was written as two directives; on
|
|
implementation it turned out to be **one**:
|
|
|
|
- ~~**Add `form-action 'self'`** (currently absent)~~ — **it was not absent.** The directives object in
|
|
`app.js` does not list it, but the middleware is configured `useDefaults: true`, and helmet's default
|
|
set already supplies `form-action 'self'` — so the header served in production has carried it all
|
|
along. Verified by capturing the live `Content-Security-Policy` header from the running app rather
|
|
than reading the config, which is how the plan got this wrong. **No behavioural change here.** It is
|
|
now written out explicitly in `config/csp.js` anyway: a security directive should not depend on a
|
|
third-party library's defaults surviving its next major version.
|
|
- **Tighten `frame-ancestors`** `'self'` → `'none'` — nothing legitimately frames the site. **This is
|
|
the entire behavioural delta of the phase.**
|
|
- Unchanged: `default-src`, `script-src`, `connect-src`, `object-src 'none'`, `base-uri 'self'`, and
|
|
`img-src … https:` (external `BRAND_*` logo/hero and `<img>` in sanitized wiki/news bodies rely on
|
|
`https:`).
|
|
|
|
The soak is still worth running for that one directive, and arguably it is the directive that most
|
|
needs one: a `frame-ancestors` report is generated by the browser of *whoever framed the site*, so it
|
|
is the only way to discover that something legitimately embeds us before the enforcing policy breaks
|
|
it. Nothing else can tell us that.
|
|
|
|
**Rollout:** ship via `Content-Security-Policy-Report-Only` with `report-to` for one release, watch for
|
|
violations, then flip to enforce.
|
|
|
|
Before trusting `script-src 'self'`: Vite's build injects an inline modulepreload-polyfill `<script>`
|
|
into `dist/index.html`, which that directive blocks (harmless, but throws a violation).
|
|
**Already handled** — `client/vite.config.js` sets `modulePreload: { polyfill: false }`, so the build
|
|
emits no inline bootstrap script. (The `renderIndexHtml` branding injection adds only `<meta>`/`<link>`
|
|
tags — no inline script, no nonce needed.)
|
|
|
|
### Where reports go
|
|
|
|
`report-to` needs somewhere to point, so the report-only PR stands up a same-origin sink:
|
|
**`POST /api/csp-report`** (`server/src/router/cspReport.controller.js`, wired in `app.js`). Same-origin
|
|
on purpose — violation reports describe attacks against this site and are not handed to a third-party
|
|
collector. It writes to the `csp` log tag and stores nothing.
|
|
|
|
It is mounted outside `/api/v1`, alongside `/api/health`: the browser learns the path from the policy
|
|
header, never from a client build, so it is not part of the versioned client contract. This is the
|
|
`+1` in the route manifest that made PR 0 go first (see § Sequencing).
|
|
|
|
Necessary properties, since it is an unauthenticated public `POST` (browsers send reports with no
|
|
session, and gating it would silence exactly the anonymous visitors worth hearing about):
|
|
|
|
- **Both wire formats.** `report-uri` (Firefox, Safari) sends `application/csp-report` with a single
|
|
hyphenated-key object; `report-to` (Chrome) sends `application/reports+json` with an array of
|
|
camelCase envelopes. Handling one silently drops half the browsers. Both directives are emitted, and
|
|
`report-to` additionally needs a `Reporting-Endpoints` response header or it is inert.
|
|
- **Always 204, even for junk.** A 4xx would make the global error handler write an ERROR line quoting
|
|
the attacker-supplied body — turning an open endpoint into a log-flood primitive. A browser cannot
|
|
act on an error from a report sink anyway.
|
|
- **Bounded everywhere:** 16 KB body cap, a per-IP rate limit, a fixed field allowlist, and every
|
|
logged field truncated (`script-sample` is attacker-influenced and can carry a whole inline script).
|
|
|
|
**Retiring it:** the sink exists for the soak. When the tightened policy flips to enforced and the
|
|
report-only twin is deleted, this endpoint goes with it — *unless* a `report-to` group is deliberately
|
|
kept on the enforced policy, which is a reasonable thing to want. Decide that in the enforce PR rather
|
|
than leaving an orphan route behind.
|
|
|
|
Tracked follow-ups (own PRs):
|
|
|
|
- **Self-host the Cinzel font** → drop `fonts.googleapis.com` from `style-src` and `fonts.gstatic.com`
|
|
from `font-src`, removing two third-party origins from the trust surface.
|
|
- **Trusted Types** — `require-trusted-types-for 'script'` + a `trusted-types` policy, report-only
|
|
first. Audit `dangerouslySetInnerHTML` + the `sanitizeHtml` render path first.
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Phase 2 — The domain split
|
|
|
|
**This is the reason the plan exists.** Everything else is supporting work.
|
|
|
|
**Rule:** one router file = one business capability; the URL names the domain; related endpoints live
|
|
together regardless of HTTP method; no generic `admin.routes.js` catch-all. Controllers are **already**
|
|
domain-split — this re-wires routes, not logic.
|
|
|
|
**Invariant:** each capability router mounts at the prefix it already owns, so the emitted URL set does
|
|
not change. Proved per PR by the route manifest (§ PR 0).
|
|
|
|
Target tree — derived from the inventory above, **inside `router/v1/`** (no `v2/` directory):
|
|
|
|
```
|
|
router/v1/
|
|
admin/
|
|
index.js # mounts the capability routers below under /admin, keeps the
|
|
# shared `noindex, isLoggedIn, staffOnly` gate in one place
|
|
users.router.js account.router.js invites.router.js
|
|
authProviders.router.js moderation.router.js botActivity.router.js
|
|
posts.router.js pages.router.js wiki.router.js
|
|
uploads.router.js shard.router.js uoLink.router.js
|
|
email.router.js discordBot.router.js settings.router.js
|
|
dashboard.router.js # + the /activity and /site-mode singletons
|
|
auth/
|
|
login.router.js register.router.js password.router.js invite.router.js
|
|
sso.router.js mobile.router.js me.routes.js (already split, 23 routes)
|
|
public/
|
|
news.router.js (posts) pages.router.js wiki.router.js shard.router.js
|
|
site.router.js # status, settings, version, contact
|
|
player/
|
|
account.router.js shard.router.js appeals.router.js
|
|
internal/ (unchanged — stays on the unpublished port, never mounted publicly)
|
|
```
|
|
|
|
Steps:
|
|
|
|
1. **Land PR 0 (route manifest) first** — the mechanical proof that later PRs move no URL.
|
|
2. Carve `admin.routes.js` into the per-capability files above, each requiring its already-existing
|
|
controller. `admin/index.js` keeps the shared gate (`noindex, isLoggedIn, staffOnly`) and mounts
|
|
each capability router at its existing prefix; the `adminOnly` / `modAccess` gates move with the
|
|
routes that use them.
|
|
3. Split `public.routes.js`, `player.routes.js`, and the remaining `auth.routes.js` groups the same
|
|
way. `auth/me.routes.js` is already a separate file and stays.
|
|
4. Keep `/internal` off the public listener exactly as today (separate `internalApp.js` port).
|
|
5. Move each route's `#swagger.*` annotations **with** the route, then regenerate
|
|
(`cd website/server && npm run swagger`).
|
|
6. Update `BACKEND_DESIGN.md` §2 (folder structure) and §4 (API contract — it names
|
|
`admin.routes.js → admin.controller.js` and friends) as routers move, plus `PROJECT_TREE.md`.
|
|
|
|
Because the auth model is untouched and the URLs are frozen, each PR is a **pure mechanical refactor
|
|
with a green test suite and a zero-diff route manifest as its acceptance criteria** — which is what
|
|
makes grouped PRs actually reviewable.
|
|
|
|
### PR 0 — the route manifest (prerequisite of the first split PR) — **landed**
|
|
|
|
> **Status: shipped.** `server/scripts/routeManifest.js` + `npm run routes:manifest`,
|
|
> `server/routes.manifest.json` (199 public + 2 internal), `server/routes.guards.json`,
|
|
> `server/test/routeManifest.test.js`, and a `routes:manifest -- --check` step in
|
|
> `.gitea/workflows/pr-checks.yml`. No router file moved. **The generator reproduced
|
|
> `api-route-inventory.json` byte-for-byte on first run**, so the freeze is in effect and the
|
|
> committed baseline is confirmed accurate rather than merely asserted.
|
|
>
|
|
> Two deviations from the design below, both deliberate:
|
|
>
|
|
> - **The unauthenticated-status snapshot was tried and dropped**, exactly as this section allowed.
|
|
> Firing unauthenticated GETs at every manifest path against the dead-port mariadb pool the tests
|
|
> use does not fail fast — the pool sits on its acquire timeout, and a partial sweep had not
|
|
> finished after two minutes. A flaky two-minute gate is worse than none. What replaced it is
|
|
> cheap and deterministic: the test suite asserts from the introspected stack that every
|
|
> `/api/v1/admin/**` and `/api/v1/player/**` route still carries `requireAuth`.
|
|
> - **`routes.guards.json` is committed and staleness-checked**, though a diff in it is explicitly
|
|
> *not* a contract change. Left ungenerated it would rot into a misleading review aid within a
|
|
> release. The gate is on freshness; the meaning of a guards diff is still "read this", not
|
|
> "justify this". The generator drops app-level plumbing (helmet, morgan, the JSON parser, the bot
|
|
> guard) since it applies uniformly to all 199 routes and would bury the per-route gates.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
"Every URL is unchanged" must be *proved by a diff*, not asserted in review. PR 0 lands the tool that
|
|
proves it, with no router file moved.
|
|
|
|
- **Generator:** `server/scripts/routeManifest.js`, wired as `npm run routes:manifest`. It requires
|
|
`src/app.js` (which exports the app and neither listens nor connects to the DB — `server.js` owns
|
|
those), walks `app._router.stack` recursively through mounted routers, reconstructs each full path
|
|
from the layer regexps, and writes a **sorted** array of
|
|
`{ "method": "GET", "path": "/api/v1/admin/users/:id" }` to `server/routes.manifest.json`.
|
|
`internalApp.js` is walked into a separate `internal` section so the unpublished port is inventoried
|
|
without being confused for public surface.
|
|
- **Scope it to the API surface, or it won't be deterministic.** Three mounts are *filesystem*
|
|
conditional: the SPA catch-all `GET *` (only when `client/dist/index.html` exists), the `/brand`
|
|
static mount, and `/api/docs*` (only when `swagger-output.json` is present — it is committed, so it
|
|
is stable). The manifest keeps only `/api/**`, `/.well-known/**`, and the internal app's routes, so
|
|
it does not change depending on whether CI built the client. Static mounts are not API contract.
|
|
- **The baseline already exists:** [`api-route-inventory.json`](./api-route-inventory.json) in this
|
|
directory is the frozen surface — **199 API routes** (110 of them `/api/v1/admin`) plus 2
|
|
internal at the time PR 0 was written. PR 0's generator must **reproduce this file byte-for-byte**;
|
|
that is PR 0's own acceptance test, and it means the freeze is already in effect before the first
|
|
router moves. *(It did, on first run. The file has since moved to **200** — the CSP report-only PR
|
|
added `POST /api/csp-report`, the first deliberate, reviewed manifest diff.)*
|
|
- **Runtime introspection, not source parsing.** It is authoritative about mounts, and the route paths
|
|
in `admin.routes.js` sit on the line *after* `adminRouter.get(`, which defeats naive greps.
|
|
- **Not `swagger-output.json`.** That is annotation-derived (only annotated routes appear) and churns
|
|
for unrelated reasons; it documents intent, the manifest records reality.
|
|
- **Frozen key: method + path only.** That is exactly the contract being preserved. Handler names are
|
|
useless as a guard check here — `requireRole(...)` returns an anonymous arrow, and router-level gates
|
|
like `adminRouter.use(noindex, isLoggedIn, staffOnly)` never appear in a route's own stack.
|
|
- **Guard coverage, separately.** The generator also emits a non-gated review aid: per route, the
|
|
handler count plus any *named* middleware collected along the mount chain. If a stable behavioral
|
|
check proves cheap, prefer it — a test that fires an **unauthenticated** request at every manifest
|
|
path and snapshots the status code catches a dropped `adminOnly` (403 → 200) in a way names cannot.
|
|
Try it in PR 0; if DB-touching public routes make it slow or noisy against the dead-port pool the
|
|
tests use, drop it rather than ship a flaky gate.
|
|
- **CI:** `.gitea/workflows/pr-checks.yml` runs `npm run routes:manifest` and
|
|
`git diff --exit-code server/routes.manifest.json`. A PR that moves a URL fails unless it
|
|
deliberately commits the new manifest — which puts the URL change in front of a reviewer instead of
|
|
letting it pass silently.
|
|
- **Published copy:** `docs/website/api-route-inventory.json` mirrors `server/routes.manifest.json` and
|
|
is refreshed in each split PR's mandatory docs edit. The markdown table above is orientation for a
|
|
human reader; **the manifest is the authoritative freeze.**
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Sequencing & PR breakdown
|
|
|
|
CSP and the split are independent; the only hard ordering is PR 0 before the first split PR.
|
|
|
|
**Resequenced during implementation: PR 0 ships first, before the CSP pair.** The CSP report-only PR
|
|
has to stand up a violation collector (`POST /api/csp-report`) for `report-to` to point at — which is
|
|
a new URL under `/api/**`. Landing it first would mean PR 0's generator emitting 200 routes against a
|
|
199-route committed baseline, so PR 0 could no longer prove itself by reproducing
|
|
`api-route-inventory.json` byte-for-byte. With PR 0 first, the collector shows up as a reviewed,
|
|
deliberate `+1` in the manifest — which is exactly the mechanism working as designed.
|
|
|
|
1. **PR 0 — route manifest.** Generator + CI check + committed baseline of today's surface. No routers moved. ✅ landed
|
|
2. **PR — CSP report-only.** Tightened policy behind `Content-Security-Policy-Report-Only` + `report-to`,
|
|
plus the report collector (manifest `+1` — the first deliberate, reviewed manifest diff). ✅ landed
|
|
3. **PR — CSP enforce.** One release later, assuming a clean violation report. **Blocked on real soak
|
|
data**, not on code: watch the `csp` log tag for `frame-ancestors` reports across one release before
|
|
flipping. Also decide there whether `/api/csp-report` is retired with the report-only twin or kept
|
|
as a `report-to` group on the enforced policy.
|
|
4. **PR 1 — admin:** `users`, `account`, `invites`, `auth` (providers).
|
|
5. **PR 2 — admin:** `moderation`, `bot-activity`, `activity`.
|
|
6. **PR 3 — admin (content):** `posts`, `pages`, `wiki`, `uploads`.
|
|
7. **PR 4 — admin (ops/config):** `shard`, `uo-link`, `email`, `discord-bot`, `settings`, `site-mode`,
|
|
`dashboard`.
|
|
8. **PR 5 — `public/*` + `player/*`** (and the residual `auth/*` grouping).
|
|
|
|
Each PR: **zero-line diff in `routes.manifest.json`**, server tests green
|
|
(`cd website/server && npm test`), Swagger regenerated, matching `docs/` edit, Conventional Commit,
|
|
AI-disclosure trailer, branch from a freshly-pulled `main`.
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Cross-component blast radius
|
|
|
|
Three independent clients consume the site's HTTP/SSE API, two of them in separate repos on separate
|
|
release cadences. **With the auth merge and the version bump both gone, the blast radius is empty** —
|
|
no client's URLs or authentication change at all.
|
|
|
|
| Consumer | Repo (cadence) | Pinning | Impact under this plan |
|
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
|
| Browser SPA | `website/client` (lockstep) | `BASE = /api/v1` in `client/src/api/client.js` | **None.** Same URLs, same cookie session. |
|
|
| Android app | `android-app` (app-store cadence, un-updatable installs in the wild) | 69 hardcoded `api/v1/…` paths; SSE path in `ShardStreamClient.kt`; SSO in `SsoAuthManager.kt` | **None.** No repoint, no release required. |
|
|
| Discord bot | `website/bot` (separate deploy, env-configured) | `SITE_PUBLIC_URL` env → `/api/v1/public` | **None.** Anonymous public reads on unchanged paths. |
|
|
|
|
Standing constraints, unchanged:
|
|
|
|
- **The public SSE stream stays anonymous.** Consumed by logged-out browser visitors *and* the Android
|
|
`ShardStreamClient`, neither of which sends an `Authorization` header. Adding `requireAuth` blacks
|
|
out the public live boards on web and mobile. The single most likely regression in a careless
|
|
refactor is reflexively wrapping *both* shard streams in auth.
|
|
- **The admin SSE stream keeps its current cookie-based gating** (`isLoggedIn`, `EventSource` +
|
|
`withCredentials`) — the rewrite that would have changed this went out with the auth merge.
|
|
- **The public/admin allowlist split is a security boundary**, not an implementation detail. Preserve
|
|
it verbatim in `utils/shardBroadcast.js` / `utils/shardIngest.js` as routes move.
|
|
- **SSO / email-connect transaction cookies are load-bearing for web *and* native.** The Android SSO
|
|
flow opens a Custom Tab to the website's `/auth/…/sso/start` and rides the same server-side redirect
|
|
transaction and the same tx cookies. Nothing in this plan touches them; don't let a future "cookies
|
|
go away" push delete them.
|
|
- **`link/` is out of scope.** The sidecar contract (`uoLinkConfig`, `utils/uoLinkClient.js`,
|
|
`utils/shardIngest.js`, `X-UOLink-Version`) is a separate versioning axis. `PROTOCOL_VERSION` does
|
|
**not** bump for this work.
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Appendix: mapping from the previous plan
|
|
|
|
| Previous | Now |
|
|
|---|---|
|
|
| Phase 0 — `/api/mobile` facade + app-version floor | **Deferred.** See § Deferred: the `/api/mobile` facade |
|
|
| Phase 1 — auth merge | **Removed.** See § Why the auth merge is out and § Deferred: the auth merge |
|
|
| Phase 1b — CSP hardening (shipped with the auth merge) | **Phase 1**, standalone; report-only-first ordering fixed |
|
|
| Phase 2 — domain split under `router/v2/` | **Phase 2**, in place under `router/v1/`; now the primary driver |
|
|
| PR 1 — `/api/v2` scaffold ([API_V2_SKELETON.md](./API_V2_SKELETON.md)) | **Superseded**, kept as the recipe if a versioned API is ever forced |
|
|
| PR final — retire v1 | **Not applicable** — v1 is never replaced |
|